Find Cheap Hotels in City Island, NY

"We love The location. Staff was wonderful. I will stay there again for sure. However I miss a coffee station in the room and readily available Ice. No bar which I found strange. The AC was quite nosey, but not enough to stop me from going back. Over all very nice"

"VERY professional staff!! Received a surprise with courtesy perks that were provided (i.e. food per diem and liberty boat cruise)! My guest and I felt like we were at home everyday we came in for the evening while staying in Times Square = the Mecca of New York!! Highly recommended and hope to stay there again !! (One minor gripe = would have been nice to have a mini-fridge available in our room). Thank you !! Damon."

"This is probably the second hotel review I’ve ever written, but my recent stay at the New Yorker absolutely warrants it. Two things, in particular, stood out. First, the amazing staff. Besides the hotel’s prime location, the staff make you feel truly welcome. For example, the doorman remembered the name of my service dog. They consistently go out of their way to provide exceptional service with a personal touch. Second, the upgrades. Unlike other hotels that claim to upgrade my room but make no noticeable changes, the New Yorker genuinely impressed me. Without any request, they upgraded my room significantly due to my extended stay. The upgraded unit had three rooms, a terrace, a walk-in closet, two bathrooms, and a stunning view of Midtown. They got it right, and I’ll be booking with them more often."

"Good location, safe, taxi service available right outside the hotel."

"Perfect location for transportation. Clean rooms. Very pleasant staff "

"Was very impressed. Our room looked just like the pictures on the website and Expedia. Was very clean and check in was a breeze "

"I always stay to this hotel every time I come to Ny. For me it is the best price for quality, location and staff"

"As always a great stay! "

"Beautiful historic building. Well cared. Amazing helpful staff "