Find 5 Star Hotels in Randall's Island, NY from ￥37,377

Very spacious room, fantastic Keihl samples (replaced everyday), great linens and lots of towels, mints by bed, the works. Elevator operator a nice touch of class in this day and age. Only downside was lack of convenient local places to get bottle of soda morning or night (the hotel charges $8.00 in room bar…are they really maximizing profits at that ridiculous price?). Otherwise, great experience from an experienced luxury customer.

SUPERB

This is a gorgeous hotel with wonderful service and amenities. Beware room service - it is extremely pricey.

Beautiful views of the park. Staff could not be more helpful and kind. Would stay there again

The Peninsula is everything you'd expect from a five star hotel, but more. The service was next level. My wife left something incredibly important to her health in the refrigerator. We realized it when we're at the Newark Airport. I contacted the hotel and the night manager actually drove to Newark airport with the package before our plane took off. Next level service doesn't say enough. Thank you Charlie!

Best service ever

I am truly obsessed with this hotel. I stay at a 1 hotel as often as I can. We stayed here last year and for some stupid reason I thought this year I would try somewhere else. I got to the other place and immediately anted to come back to 1. So we cancelled our res there and came to 1 Hotel. I will never stray again, it's so beautiful and clean and cozy and smells amazing and Jams is amazing and it's my favorite hotel on earth.

The property is very classy and well located. Neverthe less front desk staff is super slow (either the staff or the hotel's software) it took one hour to check in and the rooms were ready well after 4pm. The blind of our room (1625) couldnt be raised, we reported but nothing happened.

Love the facility. Well located.

The hotel was beautiful and perfectly located near all the great sites to check off your list. You don’t need a vehicle because parking is way over priced but your doormen/valet are so accommodating and attentive. The subway is even reasonably within walking distance to take to Time Square or to go catch a great Broadway show!

Excellent location. Close to all Broadway shows and right in Time Square. Offered an upgrade to a room with an even better view.

Luxurious. Room was large and tastefully decorated. Staff was very hospitable.

Clean , quiet. Amazing views , also the water pressure is AMAZING! Will definitely return .

Really enjoyed our stay here . Beautiful rooms , extremely clean . Great food . Staff was really friendly and helpful . Would return !

Fantastic stay! Beautiful everywhere. Brand new!

We had never stayed at the Mandarin Oriental and glad we did, very nicely decorated and the amenities were great (nice pool, fitness area, dining with fabulous views), parking on premises, close to everything. It was a little pricey, but hey, it's New York!