Astoria Vacations from ￥244,785

Stayed 3 nights for a concert at MSG. The room we were assigned smelled moldy & musty. Especially when the AC turned on. The layers of dust on the bath mirror & smoke detector were awful. Our room was an accessible room but the shower didn’t have a hand held shower. The shower head pressure was so strong & if you sat on the shower bench you’re pelted in the face. Only good thing was how close we were to the MSG & subway entrances. Construction on sidewalk outside immediately in front of the hotel made it difficult to sleep at night. Probably wouldn’t stay here again.

For this price (even if it's in new york), i would expect the room not to

First things first: if you're staying less than a week, they will add a nightly surcharge to your bill. This was not listed on Expedia. There is rarely anyone at the front desk. Everything is done electronically. It's really hard to check in by phone, and because of location, coming back at night can feel a little scary. The place is not as well kept up as previous owners had kept it. There are stains in the hall rugs. Photo-sensitive hall lights are late coming on. Two lamps in my room did not work. Don't expect maid service during your stay, nor was the room service all that complete. There were dishes in the dishwasher when I checked in. The HVAC unit is inconsistent. It resets the temperature on its own, so if you like to sleep cold, be prepared to wake up in a sweat.