Find all hotels by Highgate Independent in City Island, NY from ￥32,135

"Clean room. "

"I love the old art deco authenticity of this hotel, and the view is spectacular. The tick tock diner is so convenient and delish. Fabulous!"

"Shower gel bottle was empty upon arrival and there was long hair all over the carpet!"

"Great Stay "

"The room was great. I love the historic building even if it’s a little run down. That’s part of its charm, and the location, if you’re going to see Broadway plays, is excellent. You’re right there. A big 👍 up. "

"Buena relación calidad precio..!!"

"Nice place room was clean only thing is restraurant is not open for breakfast or lunch opens at 3 we didn't know"

"Was good, destination fees hurt it though."

"The hotel is older, which is fine because it is well maintained. However be warned that the therehold to the bathroom was raised and caused a tripping hazard. The staff could have been friendlier. We were told there was a bottle of wine in the room however there wasn’t. When we brought it up the next day the guy just walked away from us. He came back 5 minutes later and said he talked to his manager and would get us another. We didn’t ask for the bottle we were just sharing. It was odd to not have clear communication. If you store your luggage they charge a $1 per piece and then you are encouraged to tip as well. It wasn’t the easiest process. Overall the stay was fine for the night."