Find hotels in Otter Creek, NY

"Robert was very responsive. The weather didn’t work out for us but Robert’s property was excellent even better than the listing."

"Easy 10/10. Carol and Dan are so welcoming and are amazing hosts. The cottage is clean inviting and had everything we could possible need. Was an incredible place to get away for a couple days. The pond and property are awesome to explore! We cant wait to get back in the Spring/summer"

"We had an absolutely wonderful stay at this cabin. The space was spotless, beautifully maintained, and felt incredibly cozy the moment we arrived. It struck the perfect balance between rustic charm and modern comfort.The cabin was well-equipped with everything we needed, from a thoughtfully stocked kitchen to comfortable beds and inviting common spaces. We especially loved how peaceful and private the setting was — it was the perfect place to truly relax and unwind.Communication with the host was seamless and friendly, and check-in/check-out was effortless. You can tell a lot of care goes into this property and the guest experience.We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a serene, comfortable getaway. A truly memorable stay."

"This cabin was perfect for our recent stay with four adults. Remote and quiet, yet close enough to amenities. Right on a beautiful river. The snow really added to the coziness of the space. Everything was super clean, in working order, and had everything we needed. Jessica was very prompt with communication. Could not have asked for a better stay. Hopefully we can come back during the warmer months to explore even more! "

"Host and cabin was amazing"

"It was a perfect place for my family! Everything was clean and well maintained. Perfect location to old forge and is right on Moose River! Beautiful views from master bedroom. The kids and pup had a great time!"

"Was easy to find and very comfortable rooms beautiful scenery "

"Enjoyed the stay! Staff were very friendly! Rooms are a bit outdated, but we enjoyed our time! "

"Beautiful rental in a quiet neighborhood! Plenty of parking, close to trails and wonderful restaurants. The host responded quickly when contacted. All of the furniture was very comfortable. It was nice and homey and even had Netflix. The open floor plan was great for hanging out and visiting. We look forward to our next stay! I highly recommend this rental!!"