Apartments in Fire Island for Rent

"Cozy & up to date place, great for couples."

"We had a great time !!! We will definitely try to come back soon!!!"

"Me and my girlfriend had an amazing time, Deirdre was great and very helpful. Can’t wait to go back!"

"Perfect for what we needed. A great central location on Long Island in a quiet street. I will be sure to rent again in the future."

"We had a wonderful stay at this apartment. We were up in the area of my brother’s engagement party. It is in like a shared multi family house but we never once heard the other tenants. It was exactly as pictured online. The futon was pretty comfortable too! The real bed was also great. The host, Scott, was also extremely responsive. My only negative thing to say is that it did not have a cookie sheet, but we bought a foil one to use which was totally fine. They even had a whole drawer of spices...

"We really enjoyed our stay at this apartment. It’s a basement, but doesn’t really feel like it and it gets sunlight through the windows. It was really clean, plenty of dishes and silverware for the three of us. The bathroom was the best part. Very spacious with a fantastic shower. If we need a place to stay on our frequent visits to Long Island, we will stay at this great apartment."

"This home was so perfect for us. We came during the off-season for a surgical procedure and it was so wonderfully quiet. I want to say it was cozy, but people use that as a code word to mean small, and it wasn't small at all! It was definitely spacious. It was just homey and comfortable - the lighting was an especially nice bonus for us since one of us is photophobic. It was ambient and dimmable, absolutely perfect. The washer and dryer are right off the kitchen, so it was easy to do laundry....

"Really close to town"

"This was a perfect fit for what I needed: a place to stay and work that allowed easy access to Long Island and LaGuardia. The host provided a fully equipped kitchen to allow me to cook rather than eating out the whole time and was easily accessible for any questions. The off-street parking in a quiet neighborhood was welcome, while the locale was a short drive to anywhere that I needed. A great place for a peaceful and productive stay!!"

"Excellent Host was really great Everything was perfect"

"Nice, convenient location!"

"This was a wonderful location to stay for a weekend while visiting the area. Had everything we could need and the ability to sleep without interruptions."

"This property is centrally located on Long Island, which is what we were looking for. Easy to get to all highways. Minutes from the train station. Perfect for business trips. Plenty of restaurants in the area, and on the corner is a place with good pizza for take out, but the staff there is blah. Anyway, the beds at this property are comfy. Loft bedroom is quiet, and has a kick @$$ AC vent to cool the room down quickly. Rocky (the host with the most) was the best. Available 24/7. Oh, be sure to...

"Neat, clean & quite"

"I loved my stay here, everything was great and I'll definitely be back sometime soon! "

"My husband & I came to the area for a concert in NYC. We chose Vintage Living for many reasons. It is pet friendly, close to everything you may need & it is just so cute! Jess was a great host & has really done a fantastic job making this space so cozy for guests. The vintage decor was super cool. Thanks again for a grest stay! Would definitely recommend."

"Thank you very much for being so accommodating with our stay! It was very clean, had all the essentials plus extra and we really liked how we had our own private patio. Will definitely be staying again in the future!"

"Beautiful area, Beautiful place, a little noisy from the tenants above us, who you could hear walking around throughout the night. Overall would stay there again."

"We had so much fun exploring the town and the boardwalk. All very close by"

"Beautiful House that was so unique and interesting. Lovely owner and amazing that its right on the bay."

"Beautiful home in a great location with a wonderful view. Thoughtfully designed, furnished and stocked with everything you'll need. Also, great communication from the owners! Spent the weekend with teens and can't wait to return for a more relaxing adult trip!"

"We found the house to be really cute and fun to stay in. The location was excellent and we even saw a deer on our last morning! Our main issues, and why this isn’t a 5 star rating, were that multiple lighting fixtures weren’t working and there was an entire bed missing. The ad mentions “1 queen, 1 double, 4 twin’ beds however there’s really 1 queen and 4 twins. This could have caused a big problem if our group was just a bit larger. The ad should be changed to reflect the accurate information...

"The house was clean. Communication with management company was subpar. We got scripted responses to all questions, and false information. For example, we asked if hot tub was working and was told it was. When we arrived, the hot tub was broken and dirty. Also, check-out is at 10am and there is nowhere to leave belongings if you’d like to stay in FI for the day. They should allow a place to keep luggage prior to departure. Overall, great and clean house and amazing location!"