Car Rental Fire Island, NY

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Fire Island

Photo by Carole Polney
  • protection illustration

    Change your mind

    Penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals
  • trophy illustration

    Treat yourself

    Members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals
  • package illustration

    Shop smart

    Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings

Frequently asked questions

What happens if I need to cancel my Fire Island car reservation?
That won't be a problem. If you cancel your prepaid booking at least six hours prior to the pickup time, you'll most likely receive a full refund. You'll want to scan your cancellation policy as there are some exclusions. Hop on our Customer Service Portal for more info.
What types of cars can I rent on Fire Island?
Compact, mid-size or full-size ... Pick up the keys to whatever you prefer! Economy is the most sought-after rental vehicle category on Fire Island. Small, with superb fuel-efficiency and a joy to handle, these rides make driving around enjoyable. Maybe best of all? Your wallet will love them. That means you'll have more money to spend on other things, like exploring as much of this wonderful island as you can.
What are the top things to do on Fire Island?
There are endless things to do on and around Fire Island. And when you grab the keys to your rental car, you can discover them all at your convenience. You'll want to add these well-known spots to your travel plan:

  • Picturesque landscapes, walking tracks, unique animal and plant life ... Smith Point County Park makes for an awesome day outdoors. Load up your daypack with water and snacks and head out into nature.
  • A striking feature of the landscape, Fire Island Lighthouse has been a bright beacon for many travel-weary sailors. Learn about how it's helped save lives throughout the years.
  • It's impossible not to appreciate the interesting structural design of Robert Moses Water Tower, a well-known historic tower that has been able to withstand the test of time.

Why should I rent a Fire Island car with Expedia?
Expedia is your one-stop shop for all your travel needs, including car rentals. With suppliers to select from on Fire Island, we'll make sure you get an awesome deal. Whether you want to book a car, flights or a hotel, Expedia has you covered. And, as a member of One Key™, our free travel rewards program, you can save big with exclusive offers and member prices. Plus, you'll earn OneKeyCash™* on every eligible booking. Want more? Bundle your bookings into a convenient vacation package for even bigger savings on your getaway to Fire Island. *Excludes taxes and fees. OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Expedia and other participating brands.
How do I find the best car rental deals on Fire Island with Expedia?
Whatever kind of wheels you're looking for, Expedia will help you score the best deal. Simply compare offers from well-known rental providers and select the option that suits you. Love to hit the road with even more in your wallet? Combine your Fire Island car rental with flight or hotel bookings.
How old do you have to be to rent a car on Fire Island?
At least 21 years of age. Tripping around in a rental car is the best way to see Fire Island, but take note that an additional daily fee generally applies to younger drivers. A higher age limit also often applies to the rental of luxury or extra large vehicles. Be sure to have a good read over the fine print before choosing your wheels.
What do you need to rent a car on Fire Island?
Renting a ride on Fire Island requires a full, valid driver's license and a credit card in your name. If you'd like to opt out of the rental supplier's insurance plan, you're likely to need your own proof of coverage. Read through the terms and conditions of your policy to save any hassles at pickup.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer on Fire Island?
Yes, you can explore the incredible scenery of Fire Island for a month or more in one of our rentals. Just enter your travel dates and pickup and drop-off locations, and we'll find you the best long-term car rental deals around.
Where can I find a Fire Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
If you're under 25, renting a car on Fire Island will depend on the age policies of the available rental providers. Be mindful that a young renter surcharge is often applied if you're between 21 and 24 years old, and you may be limited to certain car classes. Spend time going through the fine print so there are no unwelcome surprises at the rental desk.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia