Find Romantic Hotels in Fire Island, NY

Wonderful inn with gracious hosts in this quiet B/B

Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...

nice pool I ujswed it good hot water clean I also went to the fitnesscenter and tried a feew ofthe machines all good bed excellent bathroom sink too high I like a shower not a tub shower but only a shower to stand in. get rid of the tub.

Nice hotel but way overpriced. Buffet breakfast for $18.99 is ridiculous. For $199/night breakfast should be gratis.

My stay was amazing

This hotel was surprisingly beautiful and affordable. It’s right off the LIE in a central location! Would definitely recommend!

Our business trip was amazing here! Marco ( Food & Beverages Manager) was so courteous and really took care of us gals. All the staff was pleasant. Only critique is heavier blankets for the winter. Overall, excellent.

The hotel is amazing, the staff were very welcoming. I would recommend this hotel to anyone. Great experience.

Love this place

This is a super elevated motel vibe. Area is janky but accommodations were excellent.

Great place

Overall we thought that this hotel offered great value, with free dinner and breakfast. The staff was friendly and our bedroom was very spacious and comfy. Yes, the carpet is a bit old and could use a good shampooing, but all in all, we had a great stay

We stayed at the Dansford because we were attending a bridal shower there. A unique hotel with a marina and a ferry coming next door, a lovely view. The staff was very friendly a helpful. The Dansford has a lot of character. It is old but not at all rundown. Our room was on the third floor with no elevator so you might want to ask for a first floor room if that will be a problem.

Nice quiet comfortable night

Such a beautiful property, lots of trees, lovely landscaping. They keep Crassula in pots on all of the porches as long as weather permits. The room I stayed in (double queen) was very spacious. Wood beamed ceiling with a ceiling fan, walk in shower. Loved the restaurant that was open for breakfast daily. Open for dinner Tuesday - Saturday while I was there. It's still family owned and run after 69 years. Great dining options all around, and lots to see and do on the island - although you...

Comfortable bed, ample space, beautiful bathroom

Gorgeous gorgeous hotel!! And the absolute nicest staff I have ever encountered! The restaurant breakfast wasn’t that great but everything else was 11/10!!

comfortable and relaxed stay. Rooms are nice and spacious and has a great big TV inside. The room also has a microwave and refrigerator. Everything you could need out of a hotel room.