Find all hotels by Extended Stay America in Fire Island, NY

"The property is in a great location whichnis very close to everything. Once you leave whether you turn right at the light or go straight, you can find so many things (food, dining, gas, shopping). I always stay here whenever Im in LI."

"Fits all the descriptions exactly 💯 "

"Great"

"Great staff."

"Love it"

"Great place!!"

"I loved the stay except for having to pay for parking! If we paid for a room, we should be given a sticker for our car. Don’t punish us because other people park in your parking lot!"

"Me sentí cómodo y seguro. "

"Basic amenities but we dont really come there for the hotels.....we come there for the beach. There's no public shower area thats why I book the hotel. Two years ago, I booked it just to have a place to shower. I went home at 5pm."