Find Historic Hotels in Fire Island, NY

"Not a big variety on the breakfast menu but fresh and tasty. TV interface was annoying so I gave up Parking was very convenient but I'm not sure why I was charged $10 to park Staff friendly"

"The room smell like smoke the cheat on the bed they were dirty with brown stains. Customer service was horrible. I’m not happy and I will not recommend anyone to stay at the hotel."

"Nice hotel, nice spa, nice staff, good breakfast "

"Very dirty, dirty linens, smelly, Did not stay there. Not livable. Written smoke free but everywhere is smoking smell. Terrible. "

"Room was clean, but dated. Sadly, the air conditioning did not work at all even after we had someone come take a look and supposedly fixed it. It was 74 degrees in the room at all times for two days. Breakfast is cook to serve for $15 per person. Good point, at least the don't make you pay for self parking in their parking lot like Holiday Inn Express."

"Food was great and staff we lovely "

"Had a great stay last weekend! The staff was amazing. So friendly, very helpful. The room was comfortable but the hotel is a bit outdated and run down. The lobby was very nice, but elevators and rooms could use a face lift. Overall it was a fine stay and the location was specifically what I needed but there are nicer hotels for the same cost in the area."

"Check in was great until I was told I had to pay for parking but confirmed with other friends that stood there they were not charged. i have been to this location several times and never had to pay. Bunch of smokers on the property. Major concern the cleanliness of the room unacceptable. The room appeared outdated and poorly maintained, with yellowing walls and visible signs of deterioration, i found public hairs on both my sheets & towels. I stayed for a week thinking the replacement sheets and towels would be cleaner and the same issue. I usually do not leave negative feed back but was so unhappy especially traveling from Florida just wanted to relax. "

"100"