St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum showing general coastal views and a sunset

Search Anastasia Island Cottage Rentals

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Treat yourself

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Cottages in Anastasia Island

Our top choices for Anastasia Island cottages

"This was such a great place and kid friendly and so close to everything! It was actually sad to leave. We will be back "

On the beach, sun loungers, beach towels

"Location is King! We loved the easy walk to the beach and proximity to historic downtown St. Augustine! "

"We had a wonderful stay. Nice location and plenty of room for our group of 4."

"Perfect location - best view in Sun Crest Village. Unit is a little outdated and needs some fixing up, but the location and set up with two complete apartments makes the unit worthwhile. Would stay here again. "

"What a fantastic cottage! Has everything you could need. Would definitely stay again!"

Beach nearby, sun loungers, beach towels

"We spent 6 days"

"Clean and spacious and close to the beach. Really enjoyed our stay."

"Enjoyed our time at this property, close to all things St Augustine "

"We had a great stay and love St, Augustine Beach. We have a dog and the beach and community is so dog friendly. "

"The only thing great about this property was the location, a 1 minute walk to the beach. The cottage was outdated but functional, when we arrived the it appeared that nothing had been cleaned, the showers had red and black mildew and the grease on the stove and backsplash appeared to not have been wiped in sometime, and the bed sheets had bugs in them. I purchased bleach and paper/plastic plates and utensils because I didn’t trust that anything had been cleaned. The linens provided had...

"This house was perfect for our quick trip to the beach over spring break. We rented bikes from Drifters too and cruised all over Saint Augustine Beach. Lovely few days in Florida!"

"We truly enjoyed our time at Bryn Mawr.Stephen was an excellent host and everything we needed was provided for. We look forward to staying again next year."