Search Anastasia Island Cottage Rentals

"Great stay!"

"On a quiet stretch of beach that is lovely."

"Cute and comfy! A home away from home close to the beach"

"Very comfortable! Very Clean and well equipped kitchen furnished with everything necessary for as much cooking as we wanted to do. Comfortable bed and functional bath. Close to beautiful, wide, and in May mostly empty beach. Walking distance to many good restaurants. We hope to return next spring."

"My family has campers so this little house gives me the opportunity to go “camping” with them but have my own space. Repeat customer. Really enjoy staying here."

"The location of this property is awesome, between the beach and the historic district. The view from the outside deck and pool area is beautiful, and the pool is wonderful. It is shared with another unit, but we only had people in the other unit for 1 day of our stay. The unit we stayed in is small, but it was all my husband and I needed, and it is nicely done. We could have used an oven one day (which it doesn’t have), but overall the unit was great for us. The only other problem is that...

"We had a great time. Would stay here again."

"This property is absolutely charming, and it’s a great space in a quiet neighborhood. My only feedback to the owner is to think about updating their couch and bed coverings. I would also recommend that the towels that are provide are washed the day before your guests arrivalto avoid having musty smelling towels."

"It was very nice & peaceful. Just a few steps to the beach. I did not like the stove, Complicated to use but other than that……We very much enjoyed our stay."

"Beds were a bit outdated. Other than that this place and location is amazing!"

"This cottage looks like it was recently updated and was super clean. I have not one complaint, everything was perfect and as described in the listing. Will look to this property again for future stays."

"The eclectic cottage was a gun relaxing place to stay. We would definitely consider returning. "

"The place was great walking distance from restaurants and the pier. Short drive to the old downtown. Already recommended the place to family and friends. We would stay there again!"

"It was great.Just walk out of the sunroom right outside get in the pool get in the hot tub relaxation. Total privacy. Walking distance to the beach and a lot of restaurants. Would definitely stay here again and recommend it."

"Great location, friendly neighbors. Prefect Beach get away without the hassle of large crowds."

"This cottage is a very short walk to beautiful St. Augustine beach and to several restaurants providing morning coffee to evening dinner. It had everything we needed plus plenty of parking. And downtown St. Augustine is just a 15-minute car ride away! Michael was a super host... responding quickly to answer any questions and to make our stay extra special."

"Perfect location for our itinerary at the beach."

"Wonderful stay at the Pearl. The cottage is as advertised, super cozy and loved the little details like shiplap walls, stained glass, and succulent gardens. We loved how close it was to the beach and historic St. Augustine, and loved that the beach is dog friendly as we brought our pup with us. Owners will very responsive and it’s clear they value their renters and take care of their home. Had all the basic amenities and loved the fenced in backyard! We will back!"

"Repeat stay and just as awesome as we remembered. Comfortable, cute, clean and cozy. Everything we needed and a grass yard to boot. Walk to beach, perfect! Will return as soon as we can."

"This was a great little cottage. Open floor plan helped to keep it from feeling small. The community pool was just across the parking area and it was very clean. Enjoyed reading out on the back deck most days. Will definitely consider staying again."