Search Tingler Island Cottage Rentals

"Amazing!!!"

"We loved the view from our room. Pool area was great ! It was so convenient to have the tiki bar/ restaurant so close to the property.Food was excellent ! Staff was great !"

"Awesome hotel. Clean room and outdoor areas. Awesome staff! Nextdoor bar and restaurant is a plus! Clean beach and pool. We will be back! "

"Nice clean room with kitchenette. Staff friendly, courteous, and helpful. Good amenities, pool, kayaks- no extra charge, beach, fresh bake cookies and lemonade in the afternoon. Good restaurant just down the street. Discount offered at restaurant for staying at the motel."

"Super clean "

"Overall property "

"Wonderful stay. Staff was great so polite and helpful. The grounds are beautiful. Kayaks and bikes easy to use beach and hammocks are very nice. Afternoon cookies and drinks are a nice touch the pool area is beautiful and comfortable they have a quiet swim pool as well rooms were spacious and balcony is nice couldn’t be happier with the service and stay perfect halfway stay in the keys will stay again here "

"Staff was awesome. Old Florida charm, nothing fancy. Clean, nice grounds, parking a little tight."

"Front desk staff and wait staff were great! We stayed on our way to key west and on the way back we decided to stay again. In fact as we were getting ready to leave, we couldn’t think of a reason not to stay just one more night. So we ended up staying there three nights of our five night trip. The pools were great. There was live music at the outdoor bar. The view is beautiful! Definitely will stay there again."