Find Cheap Hotels in Fire Island, NY

"If you need somewhere to stay for 4hrs okay but this hotel or better yet my room was nasty! The tub was not clean and the floors were not clean!! No toilet paper (thank god i had my wipes) yaaaaa never again! If its less than $100 maybe for 2hrs but other than that. NOO"

"The room smells like homelessness no judging but that’s not how I want to be welcomed to a room. I kept the AC so it could keep a fresh smell but it didn’t work all I got was a small cold. If you want temporary short term stay it does the job but if you’re staying for leisure this isn’t the place. "

"One person at front desk charged me by accident for something I never purchased. Stated it will be reimbursed to my card but I found this frustrating to see an additional charge on my card for no reason . Glad I monitor my credit cards daily. "

"Room was clean "

"The room was clean and there was plenty of towels. It was comfortable to sleep in. The area was also quiet. "

"They gave me a pet room, i requested a handicapped friendly room. After we settled in I noticed a strong urine smell from the carpet. We were too tired to repack and request a room change. Suffered through the odor. The rooms need renovation, staff was fine."

"Fire alarm went off 3 times in 5 days and happened last year also. "

"N/A"

"My experience was ok in some areas but definitely have feedback for the hotel staff. The restaurant service was VERY slow--there were only a few of us in the area and it took over 45 minutes to get my food, and it was terrible food. It was not cooked well (I had seafood) so you can imagine what occurred. My second night, I needed to get to bed early so I could get to the airport knowing I'd experience delays and the hotel security kept coming up to my room and banging on my door for whatever reason. I finally called the desk after the second episode (I did not open the door) and asked if the hotel was on fire or something--otherwise do not disturb me with anxious security/staff. There was no valid reason for them to bang on my door--later finding out that there was a bag of old food outside my door and they wanted to know if it was mine--why didn't they just throw it away? If it was mine, I would have brought it in my room! The hotel accommodations were fine-clean without many amenities."