The Fire Island Lighthouse is a visible landmark on the Great South Bay, in southern Suffolk County, New York on the western end of Fire Island, a barrier island off the southern coast of Long Island

Search Captree Island Cottage Rentals

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Treat yourself

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Cottages in Captree Island

Relax on the pier with lounge chairs and enjoy the serene natural surroundings.

"Very comfortable space & accomodating host! Fantastic views of Northport Harbour and steps away from the water's edge! Would return and strongly recommend."

Enjoy dining or socializing in this outdoor space with a glass table and chairs.

"Check in and check out were very easy. The owner replied quickly to my questions. The home was clean and comfortable. The location is very close to major highways with a lot of shopping and restaurants nearby. The neighborhood itself was quiet. "

Boats dock at the marina, surrounded by residential buildings.

Stunning two-story home with a gabled roof, front porch, and beautifully manicured lawn.

"Beautiful quiet neighborhood. Extremely clean apartment. Nice yard. Air conditioning was great. Missing some supplies like silverware etc. "

Cozy home with a welcoming porch and a serene lawn.

"We came to Long Island for a military retirement ceremony, this was our first time here and this cottage was perfectly located. Close to Islip airport, short drive to Port Jefferson for the ceremony, and close enough for a day trip up to the Hamptons and Montauk. The cottage itself was wonderful. Perfect amount of old and new. The landscaping and property made it feel very private."

Stunning two-story home with a central entrance, flanked by windows and a charming porch.

"Great location and great value for this stay. We will be back."

A charming single-story home with a sloped roof and inviting front porch.

Relax in this serene outdoor space with a glass-top table and comfortable seating for four, surrounded by lush greenery and a barbecue grill.

Relax in comfort on this outdoor deck surrounded by lush vegetation and a wooden staircase.

"Check-in was very simple. The neighborhood very quiet and walkable along the bay. All the amenities were available plus extras. The host was super and always reachable, much appreciated. We plan on staying again soon!!"