Find Pet-friendly Hotels in Water Mill, NY

"Thomas was the best vacation rental host we have ever had. So flexible. So responsive—before and during our stay. Very thoughtful and accommodating—he went the extra mile to make our stay great. He met us when we arrived, showed us around the house, and gave us great recommendations in the area. He brought us a blender and cooler when we asked if he had one. The house is awesome—big and nice yard, amazing pool, fun/interesting details inside, comfortable and nice, big/plenty of room for a big...

"We stayed here to celebrate our daughter’s 30th birthday. The property was better than we imagined! The home and the property are spacious and well kept. Overall, it was very comfortable and memorable! "

"The pool and hot tub are the highlights of this property. The house worked well for our family of 6 adults and 5 kids. The kitchen needs to be renovated. Couldn’t get the dishwasher and oven to work. The pots and pans are not what I would expect for this house. With a little update, this property would be wonderful."

"Wonderful home! Went out East for a Holiday shopping trip. We expanded the tradition from an overnight to a weekend. This home was perfect for our Family. Everything we would want was in place. Centrally located for both the shopping and dinners! The house was warm, inviting and well maintained. The property was in a quiet neighborhood and would be perfect for any Seasonal trip. Jo was ahead of your questions, super helpful and quick to respond. Will be back again!"

"This property was amazing and was just what I was looking for in a private Hamptons retreat. Jill was so easy to communicate with through the entire process, and she was even there to greet us when we checked in to give a tour and even left us a basket of snacks to enjoy. The property was pretty spectacular......acres of privacy with a great pool that was clean and spacious. The house had tons of room and was so clean. Horses ran around in their fenced in areas and greeted us throughout the day,...

"The house was clean and nice and modern, but the yard was the star of the stay - well outfitted and maintained, something for everyone. We had a

and a baby with us and everyone was happy. Pool is lovely and the deck has everything for lounging, grilling, and for kids to play. Would definitely rent again. "