Search Holiday Park Resorts in Windley Key

"Room was clean but room and furnishings were old, run down, and uncomfortable. Metal bed frame had rusted hardware, refrigerator didn’t work, tiny sink in bathroom had virtually no water pressure. Room was way too small for the price. Attractive view of coconut palms and Florida Bay from the room and nice sunset views. Overall needs a major remodel in my opinion. Air conditioning was noisy and because the room was so small, it was either too cold or off, which almost instantly made it too hot. Shower pressure was also too low. Hotel staff were friendly and caring. Ongoing construction of a new pool bar should have been disclosed before spending over $300/night. Not great but not a terrible experience, hence the 3-star review."

"The experience was very disappointing. The sink was clogged, and the room was not properly cleaned, there was visible dust in multiple areas. There was also no shampoo provided upon arrival, and it was only brought after calling, which shouldn’t be necessary at this level. This is definitely not what you expect from a $300-per-night hotel. There are plenty of better options nearby for the same price."

"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Perfect Stay – Already Want to Go Back! We had an amazing stay at Islander Resort and honestly didn’t want to leave! From the moment we arrived (even with a late check-in), Angela at the front desk set the tone for the entire trip. She was incredibly welcoming, fun, and went above and beyond—giving us a full tour of the property and even personally driving us to our villa since we had no idea where we were going. She immediately put us in vacation mode, and that level of service continued throughout our stay. We stayed in an oceanfront villa, which was absolutely beautiful. The setup was perfect—one king bedroom separate from the living area, plus a pullout couch that would easily work for kids or teens. The view was stunning, and having a front porch lounge area right on the water made it even better. What really stood out about this resort is how it manages to feel both secluded and social at the same time. There are so many little tucked-away lounging areas where you can relax in peace, but also plenty of space for larger groups to gather and enjoy. It’s perfect whether you’re traveling as a couple, with friends, or with kids. Speaking of kids/teens—the amount of activities available is incredible. There’s truly something for everyone, which made it a great fit for our family. Another unexpected highlight was the golf cart taxi service around the property—such a unique and convenient touch. Plus, using the Freebee app to get around Islamorada made everything so"

"The property was exactly what we were looking for. Friendliest staff and the room was great! Will definitely stay here again. "

"Amazing! Loved everything can’t wait to go back!!"

"Our sheets had holes in them and stains. The property is older but kept in fair condition. The staff was amazing! Very friendly and helpful! Also very family friendly! "

"The suite was spotlessly clean and the air conditioner worked great. The sitting area and kitchen are downstairs. The bedroom and full bath are upstairs. The stairs to the bedroom are very steep so that should be a consideration for anyone with mobility issues."

"Small shops "

"I would have liked blackout curtains and the sliding closet doors were a total wrestling match to open to the point of us just deciding to leave our clothes next to us on the beds rather than hang anything up."