Search Bay Shore Cottage Rentals

"Awesome time"

"The cottage was perfect for our stay and exactly as listed. The location is excellent, in a nice neighborhood and conveniently located to the many restaurants on Main Street. It’s only about a 50 minute drive to the wineries on the North Fork. Check in was easy and smooth and great communication from the owner. The cottage is located in a beautiful backyard that we were also able to enjoy. Would definitely rent again for a future trip."

"Cottage is very comfortable and clean. Neighborhood is quiet and in natural surroundings. Be prepared for spotty reception (screenshot access code) but WiFi is excellent in home, so is the TV/music system. Over all, excellent value and great accommodations in a beautiful spot. Only needed it for the weekend, but would book as a destination for some peace and quiet."

"The home exceeded our expectations. Beautifully decorated, very very clean, great beds and linens, roomier than expected. The only issue was not with the house, but with the management company. They gave the wrong code to enter and we had to wait for the on site manager to give us the code. The next day they gave the wrong for bike locks and we once again had to wait for the manager to come to fix the issue. Having updated and correct information provided should be high on Vacasa’s priority...

"Great area and good rental"

"Comfortable, immaculate, well supplied, wonderful location…close to family members in Bayville. Plenty of delicious nearby restaurants and markets. Lots of historical sites in area. Overall a great positive experience. And the bunny is a wonderful extra!"

"Great location and great value for this stay. We will be back."

"Needs more kitchen plates, cups, utensils. Very nice place."

"This place has perfect location to walk to beach, such a cozy home. Although we came at tail end of the residual storm flow from hurricane Ian, and road was slightly flooded- we we able to navigate easily in our rental car. Gps was not our friend but when i contacted owner he was so nice! When i return to New York i will never stay anywhere else but here again!!"

"Beautiful home in a great location with a wonderful view. Thoughtfully designed, furnished and stocked with everything you'll need. Also, great communication from the owners! Spent the weekend with teens and can't wait to return for a more relaxing adult trip!"

"We had a great time the property looked like the picture minor hiccups"