Find Beach Hotels in Pigeon Island

"St. Lucia is highly overrated. The views are nice but everything else is not worth it. Staff looks unhappy to be working there. This was a 3 star resort at best. There are locals on the beach that try to sale you things and we even witnessed a verbal altercation with a local and a guest from the hotel. The food is disgusting and has no flavor. The property smells like sewage at nighttime. Will never be back or recommend this place to anyone. I’ve been to several islands in the Caribbean and this was by far the worst experience. "

"Excellent quality "

"We had an amazing stay. The staff were incredibly friendly and went above and beyond to make everything effortless. They helped us organize our outings, arrange taxi transfers, and secure dinner reservations. A special shout‑out to Claudius, who was truly the best taxi driver—punctual, kind, and who shared so much information on the different locations we visited. The property sits directly on a beautiful, quiet beach that feels like your own private escape. A perfect place to relax and unwind."

"The rooms were a little dated, but clean. Beds were comfortable and we enjoed the swim up room. We did have difficulty booking dinner reservations. You can't book a reservation without a room number, but don't receive the room number until check-in. By that time the only times available were after 9:00. The lunch/dinner buffet was not great food was often cold or dried out. The spirts bar food was also not great and they were out of the two thjngs we actually wanted. The breakfast buffet was good as was the breakfast at Grazie, but they were only open for breakfast one day during our stay.. We really enjoyed the a la carte restaurants for dinners, especially Hunters and Zen, just wish we had been able to get an earlier reservation. We wound up missing a lot of the evening entertainment because we were eating. Drinks were a little weak as expected at an all inclusive. The staff was hit or miss on the friendliness factor. Although some did go over and above, especially Brendan and the Dips swim up bar. He was amazing 11/10 customer service with a smile. He made sure everyone was taken care of and enjoying themselves. The spa staff was friendly and provided excellent services. "

"Beach was the highlight. Beautiful waters to swim or float. Didn’t have to wake up at 5:00am to claim your chairs which was nice. We went down around 7:30 and were the first few out there. Resort is compact which is nice. Short walk to the bar, restaurant or restroom from the beach. With the surrounding restaurants in the area it would be nice if the resort offered a partial all inclusive. The one bedroom oceanfront room was excellent. Having the extra bathroom was a bonus. "

"Coco Palm is decent, locally owned 3 star hotel with a good restaurant and it’s close to the beach, shops and other restaurants. It’s a solid option for the budget traveller. We were a bit disappointed as it doesn’t look like it does in the photos on the website. The pool is nice but it’s not nearly as big as it looks in the photos on the website and on Instagram. The rooms were clean and nicely appointed but there were a few deficiencies such as taps leaking, toilet not flushing and tv not working well. All of which we could live with. It is a just 3 star hotel after all. This is not Secrets! The air conditioner was new and worked extremely well. The bed was not comfortable at all. It was like sleeping on a brick! The staff start making as much noise as humanly possible between 6-7am so don’t plan to sleep in! Most of the staff were fantastic! Some were a little cool, rude and unfriendly at first but once they got to know us many of them warmed up. We were there for a week. We are Canadians and maybe they thought we were Americans at first. Breakfast is average but it’s okay. The selection is same every day but there is a fresh egg and omelet station. Limited fruit choices. Many people loved the restaurant food but we are foodies and chefs and so found it just average. As Canadians we found the food very expensive particularly for the portion sizes. Amazing crab cakes and cocktails however! Wine is decent and is reasonably priced. "

"The views from our room were absolutely breath taking. The privacy was incredible for our occasion which was our honeymoon. The staff treated us like absolute royalty! We also thoroughly enjoyed the hike on the property, the handmade art available, and the beautiful restaurant on site. Another unique thing was the property provided us with a cell phone to contact them for anything we needed (taxi, directions, etc.) wherever we roamed in the area. We absolutely adored this place and hope to come back soon! "

"I highly recommend this resort—everything exceeded expectations. The beach was beautiful, the food was delicious, the rooms were spacious and comfortable, and the overall atmosphere was incredible. I truly have no complaints, just unforgettable memories!"

"I recently stayed at Secrets St. Lucia and unfortunately would not recommend this resort. The experience started off on the wrong foot with a very confusing check-in process that took nearly an hour. Throughout the stay, most of the staff came across as rude and disengaged, with a few notable exceptions—Sanchey, in particular, was wonderful and stood out for their kindness and professionalism. The rooms themselves were disappointing. They felt dirty and not well-maintained, although I will say the bed was comfortable and the shower had great water pressure and plenty of hot water. The food was another major letdown—bland, overly salted, and generally uninspired across the board. It felt like very little thought or care went into the dining experience. Lastly, the events and entertainment felt poorly executed—more childish than engaging, and overall thrown together without much attention to quality. For the price, I expected a much higher level of service and overall experience. I left feeling very unsatisfied—especially after a manager argued with me when I tried to provide feedback, which only added to the disappointment. Overall, this was not the level of experience I expected, and I wouldn’t choose to stay here again."