Find all hotels by Benchmark in Lower Arsnicker Keys, FL

"Amber was incredible helping us during our stay all along. It was quiet, beautiful view, nice clean room and they upgraded us to suite. My daughter and I appreciated the full size refrigerator and laundry facilities. Cleaning personell were sweet and friendly. "

"Amara Cay Resort is truly a slice of paradise! Our stay was absolutely perfect — from the moment we checked in, we were greeted by friendly, helpful staff who made us feel right at home. We stayed in an oceanfront hotel room, and the views were nothing short of breathtaking. Waking up to the sound of the waves and watching the sunrise from our balcony was a highlight of the trip. Huge thanks to the entire team at Amara Cay for creating such a memorable experience. We’ll definitely be back! "

"I have no complaints. We would definitely stay here again."

"Super like these rresort for years "

"Great property with lots of amenities "

"The property is the best for family vacation and the staff is awesome "

"Beautiful waterfront hotel. Large rooms and great area. "

"A truly pet-friendly place with everything you need in one spot — beach, pool, comfortable bed, hammock, and an on-site restaurant. Perfect for a relaxing getaway!"

"Amazing!! "