Find all hotels by Highgate Independent in Summerland Key, FL
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Summerland Key Hotel Reviews
Sugar Loaf Lodge
10/10 Excellent
"Great location for us. Clean room for 2. Ice machine worked well. Hotel employees friendly and helpful. Coming back later this year."
SEA SHELL COTTAGE, perfect for 2. Summer fun boating, fishing 🎣 and 🦞 Lobster
10/10 Excellent
"Had a great 5 night stay wish it was longer. Very clean and well appointed. Tonios was amazing. Great coffee and sandwiches at 5 brothers just down the street Pool was perfect for my morning laps. Definitely would rent again"
Open Water View from porch , golf cart, dock, bikes, kayaks, trailer parking
10/10 Excellent
"Nice gated community with family friendly features like the pool and rec-center.House was tucked away on one of the streets near the end of the neighborhood. Very well stocked house, nice and clean.We plan to reserve again in the future."
Sugarloaf Key RV Resort & Cottages
10/10 Excellent
"First time staying here it won’t be our last!"
Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort
10/10 Excellent
"The property was very clean and well laid out. Lot of great design thought went into the landscape architecture. That also applied to the rooms as well. From great lighting to a bathroom that was spacious, we felt quite at home. (Apparently, we are meant to stay in semi darkness and have a tiny shower and toilet 6 inches from the ground in the vast majority of high-priced chain hotels!) In terms of amenities, it was perfect for us. Pool, food and bar were great as was the marina where we rented a boat for the day. However the highest praise must go to the staff. They were genuinely caring and extremely friendly. Thank you for making this the best time for us."
Oceanside Paradise in the FL Keys Free Kayaks Bikes Community Pool & Hot Tub
10/10 Excellent
"Great place to stay. The whole family loved it."
Parmer's Resort
10/10 Excellent
"Parmer’s Resort on Little Torch Key is the kind of place you go when you truly want to slow down and unwind—but still have everything you need within reach. The property has a classic“old Florida” charm that is not flashy or overdone—instead, it feels cozy, laid-back, and genuinely welcoming. Parmer's has that homey, relaxed vibe that makes it easy to settle in, unplug, and enjoy the simple pleasures of the Keys. It’s the perfect setting if you’re looking to escape the hustle and just breathe for a while. It’s tucked away in a quiet spot, giving you that “away-from-it-all” feeling, yet you’re still just a short drive from great food and local favorites. Places like Kiki’s, Square Grouper, and Tonio’s are all nearby, and there’s even a fun little taco spot a few miles down the road that’s worth checking out. The amenities really add to the experience without feeling overwhelming. There’s a small private beach where you can relax by the water, plus bicycles, kayaks, and stand-up paddleboards available so you can explore at your own pace. It’s easy to fill your day with outdoor activities—or do nothing at all, which is just as enjoyable here. [parmersresort.com] Another highlight is the daily breakfast, which is such a nice touch. Having that ready each morning makes the stay even more convenient. We will be back!!!"
Waterfront 2BR Home w/ Dock + Golf Cart, Open Water Views in Venture Out
8/10 Good
"The property is on a beautiful view of water, and the communication by the host was excellent. Distance from Key West was good and allowed you to be a little outside of the fray. Three pieces of constructive feedback. We stay a lot in Vrbo‘s and the general expectation is that there is sufficient things like toilet paper, paper towel, dishwasher detergent and coffee pods for a Keurig machine that is there. These were not included, other than a starter roll of TP and paper towel. While it apparently says that in the listing, we didn’t catch it because we have grown accustomed to just having it stocked. Given the price, that would be a simple audition and would make a big difference. Labeling the three remotes in the living room, would’ve been helpful. We never could figure out the TV. And last, the golf cart is a big bonus, especially when you have aging people with you. However, the golf cart is in bad shape, it’s old and the brake needs to be fixed. Other than that, it was worth the stay."
Direct Oceanfront Cottage-Sunrise View- #2,
8/10 Good
"Not fancy but totally fine for being your home base while you check out the surrounding islands. Great yard if you have a dog!"