I'm giving this vacation condo 4 stars because we felt it was adequate and clean and met all our needs, but it was outdated and nothing outstanding. However, we enjoyed having an easy walk through the complex to the beach (which was lovely), a convenient proximity to downtown St. Augustine, and a nice safe environment throughout the condo development.
The bed was comfortable, there was a huge walk-in closet, and it was nice to have TV in both the living room and bedroom. We also appreciated the convenience of having laundry facilities in the unit. We don't share some others' complaints about the distance to the beach (it's a short walk), and the balcony hung over a side street adjacent to A1A, so the traffic wasn't right below us, as some have described.
The Ocean Village Club is clean and well-maintained overall. The heated pool was closed for most of our stay; but, after all, it isn't high season, and they have to do maintenance sometime.
We felt this was a good value for the price we paid.