This property is just as described, met every need, and exceeded every expectation! We only used the Bahama Street property for sleeping, and everyone gathered at the Duval Street property. Next time I think we will use the Bahama Street property for a dinner or two to take advantage of the kitchen opening to the pool.
The Duval Street noise was only an issue one night, and with the white noise machine provided, it went right away. We enjoyed the music next door, and the doors to the balcony are solid to block out much of the unwanted noise. The roosters were problematic a night or two for the Bahama Street house, but you're in Key West!
Parking was hugely convenient as was having the grocery store right there.
The owner was there at check in for an orientation and again at check out for any questions or concerns. He was also available during the week if needed, but we did not have any issues.