Find hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club, Shelter Island from ￥35,161

"friendly staff, great sunset"

"Everything exceeded all expectations. Excellence is a not strong enough description. "

"This was my second stay at this house, and it was just as wonderful as my first stay back in 2019. The house is large and can sleep many people comfortably. The kitchen had all the necessary amenities, and there was plenty of room to hang out and eat. Al was extremely communicative and made the check-in process easy. The house is charming, and quirky, and the perfect price-point for what my group needed for a stay in the Greenport area. I hope to return in the near future!"

"Spacious, well appointed rooms. Great location. The complimentary breakfast was cozy (nothing fancy but gets the job done). We stayed for three nights with a small dog in tow. The only surprise was that parking was not free ($29 per night) but there was plenty of free street parking available nearby."

"We had a great time staying here - Chris’s place was clean, comfortable and perfect location for exploring Greenport. We loved being able to walk so easily to all the shops and restaurants. Would definitely stay here again!"

"Great location! Very clean! "

"Lovely place, very clean, host was very responsive. Thanks so much!"

"great anf friendly, clean"

"amazing stay! "