We stay at the Islander one or two times a year. This is 4th condo we have stayed in.
Pro's: super clean, beds comfortable, comfortable furniture, easy layout, Great attention to details - lots of "extras", Nice Decor, full walls of windows towards ocean, sliding doors worked easily, Awesome view of sunsets which is not in all the condos, fast response from managing company when we had a question.
Cons: kitchen super tight - hard to maneuver, not a surplus of kitchen utensils (if need more than one spatula - bring extras), sofa too short so you will need to open into bed to use -I am 5'4", need TV instructions printed - never could get dvd player to work, super tight hallway to get into doors - mattered when we were trying to unload cart. NEEDS a way to safety latch the 2 doors Please!!
The cons are just so you can plan - not a reason to not come. This was a terrific condo and ALL 5 very picky women agreed:).