Find hotels in Fishers Island, NY from ￥9,670

"Everything"

"Couldn’t get room warm. We switched rooms and everything was fine "

"Small but very clean room, extremely pleasant front desk staff, simple breakfast with 24 hour coffee, and more than adequate parking. The price was definitely right, and I would stay here again if passing through. Note… There’s a fridge in the room, but no microwave. You can use the microwave in the lobby."

"Our family of 1 adult and 1 wheelchair using elderly adult stayed in the accessible King bed room. This was one of the better accessable rooms we've stayed in. The bathroom has grab bars by the toilet and a nice wide shower with only an inch or two above floor level. The shower has a wide bench and a stationary shower head and a lower set shower wand. The staff was amazing! They often helped us without me needing to ask. They were very accommodating to requests."

"The breakfast was fresh and hot. The rooms were comfortably appointed. The shuttle from the hotel to the casino was prompt and appreciated. "

"EVERYTHING about our stay at Gurneys was wonderful. The staff was outstanding and so accommodating. The room was beautiful looking out at the ocean. We have decided to make a family tradition to go to stay."

"Room was perfect and staff were very friendly and courteous. "

"Breakfast was great. Room was clean. Staff was very friendly "

"The staff was very courteous. We enjoyed the daily complimentary drinks and food vouchers which offset the destination fee charged at check-in. The hotel bar and restaurant were very comfortable and the menu had a nice variety of dinner entrees. We were very pleased with our stay and would recommend the Mystic Marriott."