I agree with the review that says this location's favorability is weather based, but I think it's really wind based. Also I don't think there is any bad, just different ways of enjoying it. The scene changes there based on where you are on the island and wind.
For instance, we had a westerly wind that left it pretty hot, calm and yes slightly buggy cabin-side the first day but then we expected that. Meanwhile the opposite side, (which you can hop to with provided buggy) was a sweet breeze. Next 3 days were glorious for us: easterly winds and the place was paradise. We cooked over open fire every night, kayaked, floated in the refreshing water, fished off the dock, watched the sunrise from the back patio mornings (thats the pic they should include on this listing!) and even took the buggy to the opposite side of the island to see sunsets. We did all of this having 2.5 and 1 yr old babies with us! If you're all adult party, you could kayak around the whole island, no doubt!
We too were a bit nervous about supplies, but it works itself out. I gave the cleanliness 3 stars because being so remote the owners have limited cleaning resources and the crew before us was a guys fish fry trip - still it was not that bad, and we honestly didn't care we were so comfortable.
Only real complaint from my wife was the handmade wooden rocking chairs - the legs are sharp and she stubbed her toes at least 3 times! Watch out for them, other than that - if you're reading this, and there are available dates, better bookit!! Best family retreat we've ever had! -Billy & Lauren