We enjoyed our stay at Casa Coralina (2 families with 3 children 9-11 y/o) in early August.
The good: the listing is accurate, the house absolutely stands out in how well it is decorated for a rental house, the beds were reasonably comfortable, the grounds are well maintained, the shared pool is wonderful, and it was great to have a grill outside and pool floats for the kids. Also Pilar the property manager is a gem and you should absolutely follow her restaurant/snorkeling/massage recommendations!
The less good: cleanliness was at best a 3/5 (lots of dust, lots of cockroaches despite a recent fumigation, and dirty plates and pots in the cabinets), the dishwasher doesn’t work properly, and the shower pressure in the guest room was so low we called it the mister and barely used it.
Nevertheless, we enjoyed our stay at Villas Sole and that’s despite the ton of sargassum on the beach and in the ocean at this time of year. The beach looks amazing and the sunsets are magical. If the house was maintained better this would have been 5/5 for us because it is such a unique and beautiful property.