Find Boutique Hotels in Long Island

"We liked the resort because it was small and only had 50 cottages. We had minor issues with the quirky outdoor shower that seemed to have a mind of its own and the AC unit which would not respond to input from the remote. The bed was fairly comfortable and the room was kept stocked with what we needed. There was a nearby stage set up on our first night that blared music constantly from 4pm until after midnight. Thankfully it was only one night or our stay would have been terrible. There is only one main restaurant but the menu changes nightly and every meal was excellent."