Checking in was easy - we parked outside the town walls, walked past the church and found the key box as instructed. Although it was late evening, everywhere was still buzzing so had a meal and drinks in one of the squares, feeling grateful for Spanish hours.
We didn't see the owners to speak to, so no worries about privacy if anyone is concerned about that. The agent was friendly and helpful and easy to communicate with - we were suffering with the heat and humidity and they arranged an extra fan the same day, many thanks!
The apartment has been sympathetically renovated and the space and facilities were great. The only downsides were the heat (as mentioned above), as it is ground floor there is not much of a breeze (being in a walled city obviously doesn't help) and we struggled to sleep. Air conditioning would be a massive improvement. We were also tormented by mosquitoes although that is hardly the owners fault!
The other issue was poor wi-fi connection - it dropped out constantly and drove our teenagers mad. Could be improved.
However, these are by way of constructive criticism. We found the house spacious, fab location and well equipped. Had visited Alcudia before but great to stay there, both discovering new things (the sculpture park at Fundacion Ben Jakober is a must if you have a car) and re-visiting old favourites such as Port de Pollensa. A brilliant location to explore the north of Majorca. Parking is easy, wandering around the town is safe and exploring further afield pays dividends (we also recommend Jardines de Alfabia - especially on a hot day, lovely shade and home made lemonade). If you want a resort full of restaurants the port is not far away so you have the best of both worlds - a beach if you want it (watch out for the flat fish in the shallow water) and a more interesting historic town to enjoy. Check out the Flamenco show at the bull-ring - worth it for the guitarist alone. Also, the market has great fruit and veg as well as the obvious tourist stuff and the pottery lady has great prices.
We enjoyed our stay, we always love to peer in behind big old doors and see what's inside - here you can go in and leave the passers by wondering!