Search Sodus Point Cottage Rentals

"Our experience was very good. We enjoyed our visit very much. Our room was cozy and welcoming. We had a few unique experiences that might help others to be aware of in the future. The hot water heater was very small which was fine, however, not knowing this we ran out of hot water during the first shower which left only cold water for my shower and we had a funeral to attend so that made it very inconvenient. Had we known we could have planned accordingly. Our second experience was that wiring fo one of the lights seemed to be connected incorrectly and sparks actually flew out of the wall (scary and definitely unexpected) when we touched the cord and it caused the breaker to switch to off turning off two walls of electric outlets and the tv. This was quickly addressed which we appreciated. Our villa did not have a paddle to move the water around in the hot tub and the thermometer didn’t appear to be working correctly. Keep a close eye on your water temp in the hot tub. Once it gets close to an acceptable temperature slow up on feeding your fire. The night we got it to a lovely temperature the hot tub feature was so lovely and the reason we booked at this unique property. Try some local restaurants. We went out for subs at Fork and Flame and a nice breakfast in the morning at Scrumpchies. I was hoping for a conversation about the electrical mishap in our room from the owners with some type of compensation but with the exception of that our time was enjoyable."

"Would rent again."

"Great hotel to stay at for local historical site visits. "

"Fast check in and friendly, professional front desk staff. I stayed 3 nights. They state that breakfast is “continental” and that’s exactly what is offered so people shouldn’t complain. The machine dispensed coffee is pretty awful. I had a standard king room and it was clean and good sized. They do need to add another chair to the room. The only chair is at the desk which faces a wall with your back to the tv so your only choice to watch tv is on the bed. They have some nice touches with cookies and whole fruit available all day. If I’m in the area, I would stay here again"

"The house was perfect for we four fishermen. Plenty of room, the kitchen was well appointed and the there were plenty of towels. The hot water was plentiful as were the paper goods. We will rent again next year."

"Great, quick communication. Beautiful home."

"It was a great weekend get away!! We had beautiful weather for fishing and fun. The house was perfect for what we were looking for. Thank you. There are only 2 spoons. That made eating yogurts tricky for 7. But we survived "

"Everything was great! Host was very responsive, and the kitchen was well stocked with paper products, spices, condiments, etc so we didn’t have to buy them. "

"We stayed at Sodus bay view for Christmas weekend2025. The property was clean and was the perfect place for our family to “meet in the middle” for the holiday. The kitchen was very well equipped and had a nice assortment of glassware , pots pans and silverware. The beds were comfortable and even though we provided our own linens for each it didn’t deter from comfort or the over all experience. The water was HOT and shower pressure good. Nice view of the bay and neighborhood/beach. The dogs enjoyed long walks around before the snow blanketed the town. First floor bathroom and bedroom were a must for my elderly dad who joined in on the family fun. "