We spent the last three days of our 10 day vacation here and this was the best of our rentals (including Disney's Caribbean Beach Resort). The space is roomy. We appreciated the soft bedding, variety of pillows, plush towels, beach umbrellas/chairs, and tasteful decor. It is convenient to get to Siesta Key beaches. Lovely plantings in the garden (we didn't use the outdoor space so can't comment on hot tub, etc.).
The overall rating is 4 rather than 5 because of 3 issues: 1. No matter how fast I went, I ran out of hot water in the shower. 2. There wasn't a king size sheet for the (very comfy) bed (BUT--I didn't ask the host who may have had one elsewhere). 3. The neighborhood is a little run down, couch on the road across the street & signs of neglect (but not by this homeowner).
I would stay there again.