Rock Cabin was a quiet and peaceful place to stay. It was spacious for the 2 of us, with lots of windows to enjoy the views. We enjoyed our walks down to the river and lake. Redwing blackbird fledgings were on the ground, and three geese pairs had goslings on the lake.
The only downside was, because of our schedule being away most of the day at a family reunion, we weren't able to connect with the hosts to pay our pet fee via credit card. I thought we'd have the cash to pay, but it turned out we were short of cash after paying some other costs. The directions state to pay the pet fee via credit card upon arrival, but I never did figure out where or how to pay this fee, although I left messages as to when we'd be at the cabin. I told people on the grounds we'd be leaving early on our day out. We left most of our remaining cash on the table (we weren't able to use debit cards to get cash at the store).
This is why I give this location 4 instead of 5 stars.
It would also be helpful, if possible, to have reflector lights indicating where the driveway turn is. If you are returning from Pagosa Springs at night like we were, it's really dark on the road at twilight/night. We found the driveway by locating the bright yellow spotlight on the barn.
Otherwise, this was a wonderful stay and we were able to recommend it to family members who had been looking for, but couldn't find, a (safe)place to bring their dogs to Pagosa Springs.