Stayed at Surf Shack for our first time during our annual Thanksgiving weekend trip. As such, we've stayed at a few comparable properties over the years. It was as cozy as the name implies; however, it truly is a very seasoned cottage in terms of its structure and condition: an old beach shack that needs some TLC investment inside and out. The main living spaces offered everything we needed for a weekend trip to the area and a place to crash at the end of the day after watching some TV in the evenings. The living room was fine for a couple people to kick back and watch the 50" smart TV with soundbar. The kitchen had all the essentials for our limited needs. The queen bed was fine for a couple nights but the small smart TV was strangely mounted on the wall crooked.
The side porch had come to be used as storage for assorted beach gear and wasn't really furnished or usable as a place to sit and relax, which sadly was something we typically look for and expected based on the profile pics. The front porch Adirondack bench was very comfortable for sitting with coffee and cocktails. The location overall was also very convenient to the beach, shopping, and restaurants. We noted that VA Dare Trail in that section of Nags Head seemed pretty busy and loud (day and night) compared to the more southern area of Nags Head but it was fine.
Owner was very responsive at check-in when we contacted her to get the lockbox code, which has not been sent in advance. The issue was quickly resolved and the other property info we'd received was very helpful. Overall, Surf Shack served it purpose for our brief stay. However, time is catching up with it as a structure and the comfort level of its furnishings in today's competitive vacation rental marketplace.