We've stayed at this house for a few years and love it.
Things we love about the house: the location is ideal being so close to downtown Duck and the beach, having a real garage (which is rare in this area), having extra bikes in the garage is a nice perk, very nice pool and hot tub, having two master bedrooms, the beds are very comfortable, the kitchen is nicely stocked with cooking equipment (which has been an issue at other homes), they have a nice selection of games/books during rainy days, and the screened in porch off the kitchen is a great place to eat or let your clothes dry.
The house could be a little cleaner. As a rental, I don't expect it to be perfect, but I found myself noticing dirty baseboards, corners, shower crevices this year. I'm a clean freak so it would likely go unnoticed by most. I'd also prefer a gas vs. charcoal grill.
All in all this is a wonderful place to stay and very close to perfect IMO. We will rent this house again and I'd even buy it if it was for sale!