This was our 3rd trip to Maui and first time staying in the southern Maui area (we typically stay Lahaina side). I can say that Makena Surf exceeded our expectations. It hit every checkbox - value, location, convenience, and experience. Ever visit somewhere and say I'd like to live here? That was our experience.
Although we booked through VRBO, Ali'i Resorts manages unit C-103 among a number of other units. This was our first experience with Ali'i and they were wonderful as well.
The property is beautiful. Well kept grounds within very short walking distance to a pristine beach. There are multiple buildings on property that offer different views of Maui and different price points as well. Our particular unit was well maintained and had all the amenities you'd expect with a small family (2 young girls).
You're situated almost on top of one of the best snorkeling spots on the island. The beach and surf on location is good. If you feel like traveling to another amazing beach, you're only 5-15 min away from some of the best choices. You're also close/far enough away from Wailea that you have access to good locations to eat, drink, and shop.
I can't say enough good things about this property. I will only say that this property should satisfy anyone regardless if it's your visit to Hawaii or your a regular.