I will absolutely be returning to this property in the future. The hotel itself was quaint and clean, the restaurant was delicious, the pool bar was amazing, and the coffee shop was a must-visit every single morning of my stay! (Try the vanilla latte, it's incredible.)
I will say, what makes Wayfinder an exceptional destination is the STAFF. From the employee that assisted with check in, to the valet that parked my rental car, I didn't have a single interaction with a staff member that wasn't warm, helpful, and full of personality. I also thought it was unique and cute that their zodiac signs were included on their name tags - I've never seen this before and it was something that stood out from the norm.
Despite the weather being particularly rainy and windy during my stay - it was one of my better visits to the island because the hotel/parking was effortless! Special shoutout to Charles for always making me smile.
The only thing that I would suggest as an improvement, was that wifi/check out time wasn't quite clear and had to be asked about - and the hot tub was unfortunately...not hot. Since it was windy and chilly (for the area) it would have been nice for the hot tub to be heated more than just lukewarm. It was more of a "warm" tub than a hot tub.
Since I didn't spend much time at the pool/hot tub, it didn't detract from the trip at all - but is still worth noting to the hotel as a possible improvement. Mahalo for the wonderful staff, and their service!